Introduction
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is scheduled to address the U.S. Congress on July 24, 2024. His visit comes amid Israel’s ongoing conflict with Hamas in Gaza. Many Congressional Democrats are conflicted about whether to attend his speech, reflecting broader tensions within the party.
Historical Context
- Previous Boycott: Nearly 60 Democrats boycotted Netanyahu’s speech to Congress in 2015. They saw it as disrespectful to then-President Barack Obama, who was negotiating a nuclear deal with Iran.
Current Concerns
- War in Gaza: Since the conflict began on October 7, over 37,000 Palestinians have died from Israeli fire. The Palestinian Health Ministry reports these casualties, though they do not distinguish between civilians and combatants.
- Democratic Dilemma: Many Democrats are struggling to reconcile their support for Israel with their concerns over its military actions in Gaza. The situation has created a divisive atmosphere for Netanyahu’s upcoming address.
Views on Attendance
Arguments for Attending
- Respect for Israel: Some Democrats feel it is important to show support for Israel by attending the speech, regardless of their views on Netanyahu. Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-N.Y.) says he feels an “obligation” to attend because of his position on the House Foreign Affairs Committee.
- Educational Opportunity: Rep. Michael McCaul (R-Texas) believes it’s essential for Congress members to hear Netanyahu’s perspective to understand the complexities of the conflict.
Arguments for Boycotting
- Protest Against Netanyahu: Many Democrats see Netanyahu’s invitation as a Republican tactic to divide their party. They criticize his handling of the war and oppose his stance on peace with Palestinians.
- Alternative Events: Some Democrats, like Rep. Jim Clyburn (D-S.C.), are planning alternative events to discuss paths to peace for Israelis and Palestinians.
Internal Party Tensions
- Criticism from Party Leaders: Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and other prominent Democrats argue that inviting Netanyahu was a mistake. They worry it will increase discontent within their party.
- Public Discontent with Netanyahu: Public opinion in Israel is also shifting against Netanyahu, affecting his support among American Democrats.
Biden Administration’s Response
- Conflicting Messages: Tensions between Netanyahu and President Joe Biden have become public, with Netanyahu accusing the Biden administration of withholding U.S. weapons from Israel—a claim the White House has denied.
- No Scheduled Meeting: Despite Netanyahu’s visit, no meeting with President Biden has been planned.
Conclusion
The decision to attend Netanyahu’s address to Congress reflects deep divisions among Democrats over U.S. policy toward Israel. While some view attendance as a necessary gesture of support for Israel, others see it as endorsing Netanyahu’s controversial policies and handling of the Gaza conflict. This ongoing debate highlights the complexities of international diplomacy and domestic politics within the U.S.
Table of Contents
